Episode 210: Historians At The Movies: The Outlaw Josey Wales with Matthew Hulbert


Episode Summary

Is The Outlaw Josey Wales a Western, a Civil War movie—or John Wick on horseback? Historian Matthew Hulbert joins Jason Herbert to revisit Clint Eastwood’s 1976 classic and explore the brutal history behind its tale of revenge, survival, and unlikely friendship.

From the guerrilla warfare of Missouri and Kansas to the Confederate veterans who became outlaws, we examine where the film captures the Civil War’s intimate violence—and where it turns history into mythology. Who were the bushwhackers and Jayhawkers? What happened to guerrillas after Confederate surrender? And how does Josey Wales become a sympathetic Confederate hero in a story that leaves slavery offscreen?

We also discuss the troubling background of novelist Forrest Carter, his identity as segregationist Asa Carter, and the contradictions surrounding his portrayals of Native Americans. Through Lone Watie, Ten Bears, and the film’s makeshift community, we consider Indigenous representation, federal power, and the connections between the Civil War and westward expansion.

Along the way: Eastwood versus John Wayne, our favorite Civil War films, Kevin Costner’s Western ambitions, and spirited detours through Tombstone, Unforgiven, and Old Henry. It’s a funny, candid conversation about loving a movie while asking hard questions about the history it tells.

Follow Reckoning with Jason Herbert for more conversations about history, movies, and how we remember the past.


About Matthew Hulbert

Matthew Hulbert is an Elliott Associate Professor of History at Hampden-Sydney College. His research revolves around nineteenth-century America with special interests in the American Civil War, guerrilla warfare in the western borderlands, Civil War memory, film history, and the western frontier. In addition to being a Series Editor for American Wars and Popular Culture at LSU Press, he writes a regular column — called “Observatory” — for The Civil War Monitor and appear regularly on RadioNemo for “Beyond the Bushwhackers.”

Studying under John Inscoe, he received his Ph.D. from the University of Georgia in 2015 after spending 2014 as a H. F. Guggenheim Foundation Fellow. His dissertation received both the 2016 C. Vann Woodward Prize from the Southern Historical Association and the 2015 Lewis Eldon Atherton Prize from the State Historical Society of Missouri. He is the author or editor of five books, including The Ghosts of Guerrilla Memory, which received the 2017 Wiley-Silver Prize, and Oracle of Lost Causes: John Newman Edwards and His Never-Ending Civil War, which was a finalist for the 2024 Spur Award in Western Biography. Additionally, his work on guerrilla warfare, Civil War memory, the West, and pop culture has also appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Kansas City Star, The Civil War Monitor, the Western Historical Quarterly, Civil War History, Common-Place: The Interactive Journal of Early American Life, the Journal of the Civil War Era, and the Journal of the West. At Hampden-Sydney College, he teaches courses on the American Civil War and Reconstruction, the History of Hunting and Fishing in America, and the American West in History and Film, along with various seminars and introductory surveys.

You can find him on Instagram @the_outdoor_professor.

Representation: Roger Williams, The Roger Williams Agency.

Next
Next

Episode 209: My Life with Pandas with Dr. Brandie Smith